Why Life Insurance Claims Get Denied
Life insurance claims are denied on several grounds: material misrepresentation in the application (undisclosed medical conditions, tobacco use, hazardous activities); death during the two-year contestability period; exclusions (suicide within the first two years, death during illegal activity, aviation exclusions); policy lapse for non-payment of premiums; and in some cases, disputes about whether the death qualifies as an "accident" under an accidental death policy.
The contestability period is one of the most significant: during the first two years of a policy, insurers can investigate and deny claims based on any material misrepresentation in the application—even ones unrelated to the cause of death. After two years, the policy becomes incontestable (with limited exceptions for fraud).
Misrepresentation: What Is "Material"?
Not every omission in an application justifies denial. To deny a claim based on misrepresentation, the insurer generally must show the misrepresentation was material—that is, the insurer would not have issued the policy (or would have issued it on different terms) had it known the truth. A failure to disclose a minor medical condition that had nothing to do with the cause of death may not be material. The insurer bears the burden of proving materiality.
Accidental Death Policy Disputes
Accidental Death and Dismemberment (AD&D) policies cover only deaths from accidents, not illness or natural causes. Disputes arise when: the death involved both accidental and medical components (a fall triggered by a heart attack—which came first?); the insurer argues death resulted from "disease or bodily infirmity" rather than accident; or the cause of death is disputed. Autopsy reports, medical records, and expert forensic testimony often determine the outcome.
Filing a Complaint and Legal Remedies
If your life insurance claim is denied, request a complete copy of the claim file under your state's insurance regulations. File a complaint with your state's Department of Insurance. If the denial lacks a reasonable basis, a bad faith claim against the insurer may be available—in some states, bad faith in life insurance denial carries punitive damage potential that creates substantial insurer exposure. Most states have specific procedural requirements before filing a bad faith lawsuit.
Get your life insurance denial reviewed →
Discuss your case with Yates Anderson
Yates Anderson represents clients in Alabama, Florida, and beyond. Our attorneys handle complex disputes with the rigor of a national firm and the agility of a boutique. Request a case evaluation and an attorney will respond within one business day.
Frequently asked questions
Can a life insurance company deny a claim because the insured died from a pre-existing condition?
If the policy is past the two-year contestability period, the insurer generally cannot deny the claim based on undisclosed pre-existing conditions unless the misrepresentation was fraudulent. Within the contestability period, the insurer can investigate and deny if the undisclosed condition was material to the policy issuance decision—even if the pre-existing condition wasn't the cause of death.
What is a "slayer rule" and how does it affect a life insurance claim?
The slayer rule prevents someone who intentionally kills a policyholder from receiving the life insurance proceeds. If the beneficiary is charged with or convicted of killing the insured, the insurer will typically withhold payment pending the criminal and civil proceedings. If the slayer rule applies, proceeds go to contingent beneficiaries or back to the estate. Insurance companies are not required to wait for a conviction before withholding payment.
How long does a life insurance company have to pay a claim?
Most states require life insurers to pay or deny claims within 30–60 days of receiving proof of death documentation. Some states impose interest penalties for late payment. If the insurer has not responded to a properly submitted claim within the statutory period, filing a state insurance department complaint and consulting an attorney about bad faith liability is appropriate.