Start With the Denial Letter
Your denial letter is the foundation of your attorneyseal. Read it carefully to identify: the specific policy provision or exclusion cited as the basis for denial; the factual findings the insurer relied on; the documentation they reviewed; and the internal appeal process and deadlines the letter describes. Every effective appeal directly and specifically addresses the stated reason for denial with evidence and argument tailored to that specific reason.
Gather Your Evidence
Different types of claims require different supporting evidence. For property damage denials: independent contractor estimates; expert opinions on cause of loss; weather service records; photos documenting the timing and nature of damage; and prior inspection reports showing pre-loss condition. For injury claim denials: treating physician narrative reports; medical records; specialist opinions; functional capacity evaluations; employment records documenting lost wages. For health insurance denials: physician letters of medical necessity; clinical guidelines supporting treatment; peer-reviewed literature; and documentation of prior approved similar treatments.
Write a Clear, Organized Appeal Letter
Structure your attorneyseal letter: (1) state that you are formally appealing the denial of claim [number] for [coverage]; (2) identify the specific basis for denial stated in the denial letter; (3) explain specifically why that basis is wrong or does not apply, citing policy language and evidence; (4) list all attached supporting documents; (5) state clearly what you are requesting (reversal of denial and payment of [amount]); (6) provide your contact information and a deadline for response. Attach all supporting documents as organized exhibits. Keep a complete copy of everything you submit.
If the Internal Appeal Fails: External Options
If the internal appeal is denied, escalate to: (1) the insurer's executive resolution department or state insurance department consumer advocate programs; (2) your state's Department of Insurance (complaint and investigation); (3) external review programs (for health insurance denials); (4) appraisal process (for property amount disputes); and (5) legal counsel for bad faith claims, coverage disputes, or claims with significant value. An attorney who specializes in insurance claims can evaluate your specific situation and advise on whether legal action is warranted and likely to succeed.
Get your insurance denial evaluated →
Discuss your case with Yates Anderson
Yates Anderson represents clients in Alabama, Florida, and beyond. Our attorneys handle complex disputes with the rigor of a national firm and the agility of a boutique. Request a case evaluation and an attorney will respond within one business day.
Frequently asked questions
How long does an insurance company have to respond to an appeal?
Most state prompt payment statutes require insurers to acknowledge appeals within 10–15 days and respond within 30–45 days. Health insurance appeals have specific federal timelines under ACA rules. If the insurer misses the response deadline, document the delay and file a state insurance department complaint—delays without explanation can support bad faith allegations.
Should I hire an attorney to write my insurance appeal?
For small claims (under $5,000–$10,000), self-representing is often economical, particularly when the denial is based on a clear factual error. For significant claims—large property damage, serious injury, disability, life insurance—attorney involvement typically produces substantially better outcomes. Many insurance attorneys work on contingency for denied claims, meaning no upfront cost and payment only if they recover for you.
Can I sue my insurance company if my appeal is denied?
Yes. If your insurer wrongfully denied your claim—meaning the denial lacked a reasonable basis—you can sue for breach of contract (the policy benefits owed) and potentially for insurance bad faith (additional damages and attorney fees). In most states, you must exhaust internal appeals before filing suit for contractual benefits, but bad faith claims can sometimes be pursued simultaneously or before the internal process concludes. Consult a local insurance attorney about your state's specific requirements.