HOA Authority and Its Limits
Homeowners associations derive their authority from three sources: the Declaration of Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions (CC&Rs); the bylaws; and state law. HOAs can enforce rules, assess regular and special assessments, place liens on property for unpaid assessments, and in extreme cases, foreclose. But this authority has limits—HOAs must follow their own governing documents and applicable state law, and boards that act outside their authority face legal challenges.
Many HOA disputes arise because boards either (1) enforce rules that don't actually appear in the governing documents; (2) apply rules selectively to some owners but not others; (3) fail to follow the procedures required before fining or assessing; or (4) adopt new rules without proper member vote. Each of these is challengeable.
How to Challenge an HOA Fine
Most state HOA laws and governing documents require the board to give you written notice of the violation, an opportunity to cure it, and a hearing before the board before imposing a fine. If the board skipped any of these steps, the fine may be procedurally defective regardless of whether you actually violated the rule. Request the specific rule you allegedly violated, in writing from the CC&Rs—not just board policy. If the rule doesn't appear in the CC&Rs or was adopted without proper notice and vote, it may be unenforceable.
Selective Enforcement as a Defense
If your HOA enforces a rule against you but ignores the same violation by other homeowners, you may have a selective enforcement defense. This requires documenting the non-enforcement—photographs of similar violations by other owners that went unpunished. Courts in many states have held that selective enforcement prevents an HOA from enforcing a rule against the homeowner who was treated differently, even if the rule itself is valid.
Special Assessment Disputes
Special assessments—one-time charges for major repairs or capital improvements—must typically be approved by either the board or the full membership depending on the amount and the governing documents. Large special assessments without proper member vote authority, inadequate notice, or improper methodology are commonly challenged. An attorney can quickly review whether the assessment followed required procedures and whether the underlying project falls within the HOA's authority.
Get your HOA dispute reviewed →
Discuss your case with Yates Anderson
Yates Anderson represents clients in Alabama, Florida, and beyond. Our attorneys handle complex disputes with the rigor of a national firm and the agility of a boutique. Request a case evaluation and an attorney will respond within one business day.
Frequently asked questions
Can an HOA foreclose on my home for unpaid dues?
Yes, in most states HOAs can place a lien on your property for unpaid assessments and then foreclose to collect. The procedures and thresholds for HOA foreclosure vary significantly by state—some require judicial proceedings, others allow non-judicial foreclosure. Unpaid HOA dues and the resulting lien can also disrupt a future sale or refinancing. Never ignore assessment notices; address disputes formally while staying current or placing disputed amounts in escrow.
What if I disagree with the HOA board's decision at the hearing?
Most HOAs provide for an appeal to the full board after the initial hearing committee decision. Beyond that, many states have mandatory alternative dispute resolution (ADR) for HOA disputes before litigation. State HOA dispute resolution programs vary—Florida, California, and several other states have specific regulatory or mediation programs. Review your state's HOA dispute resolution requirements before filing a lawsuit.
How do I run for the HOA board to change the rules I disagree with?
HOA board seats are filled through elections governed by the bylaws. Notify the board of your intent to run, follow the nomination procedure in the bylaws, and campaign among your neighbors. State laws governing HOA elections—particularly in Florida and California—have specific procedural protections designed to prevent incumbents from manipulating elections. Know your state's HOA election rules before nomination.