Comparison · Property Insurance
Alabama vs Florida first-party bad faith
Two doctrinally different bad-faith regimes
Both states recognize first-party bad faith as a tort separate from contract, with damages potentially exceeding policy limits. The mechanics differ materially. Alabama's common-law framework recognizes "normal" and "abnormal" bad faith; Florida codifies the cause of action with statutory prerequisites.
| Dimension | Alabama (Brechbill standard, common law) | Florida (Fla. Stat. § 624.155) |
|---|---|---|
| Source | Common law (Chavers, State Farm v. Brechbill line) | Fla. Stat. § 624.155 |
| Normal bad faith standard | No debatable reason to deny | Not how to act fairly toward insured (statute) |
| Abnormal bad faith standard | Intentional or reckless mishandling beyond mere debate | Not codified separately; statute covers spectrum |
| Pre-suit notice | Not required | Required — civil-remedy notice under § 624.155(3) |
| Cure period | None statutory | 60 days for carrier to cure after notice |
| Damages available | Contract benefits + emotional distress + punitives (egregious) | Contract benefits + interest + reasonable damages + attorney's fees |
| Punitive damages | Available; case law extensive | Available under common-law theories layered on statutory claim |
| Attorney's fees | Per contract; not statutory | Statutory under § 624.155 (subject to recent SB 2A changes) |
| Forum | Circuit court or federal (diversity) | Circuit court or federal (diversity); arbitration where contract specifies |
Strategically, Florida's pre-suit notice and 60-day cure period operate as a settlement mechanism: carriers that pay the underlying claim during the cure window typically defeat bad faith on that claim. Alabama's framework lacks the cure window — the insurer is exposed to bad faith from the moment of an unjustified denial, with no statutory grace period.
For Alabama claimants, the strategic challenge is articulating which prong ("normal" or "abnormal") fits the facts. For Florida claimants, the strategic challenge is correctly satisfying the § 624.155 civil-remedy-notice prerequisites — failure to comply is fatal to the statutory claim.
Request a case evaluation · Property Insurance practice page